不同预处理方法对青贮玉米秸秆厌氧消化产气效能的影响

    Effects of different pretreatment methods on the biogas production efficiency of ensiled maize stovers during anaerobic digestion

    • 摘要: 为提高青贮玉米秸秆的厌氧消化产甲烷效能,该研究从理化特性、元素组成、微观结构等角度,分析了NaOH、γ-戊内酯(gamma-valerolactone,GVL)/NaOH、碱性过氧化氢、芬顿试剂4种预处理方法对青贮玉米秸秆产甲烷性能、厌氧消化系统稳定性和反应进程的影响机理,并比较了不同预处理条件下的能源转化效率和经济效益。结果表明,与原料(CK组)相比,预处理后的NG1组(摩尔比0.1/1的GVL/NaOH预处理)中纤维素含量由41.35%提升至69.21%,半纤维素含量由8.76%提升至17.77%,木质素含量由14.77%降至5.56%。微观结构显示,NG1组的木质纤维结构被严重破坏,总结晶度指数显著降低(P<0.05)。进一步,NG1组的累积甲烷产量高达375.17 mL/g(以挥发性固体计),较CK组提升了26.08%;理论最大产甲烷速率(Rm)较CK组提升了25.43%;迟滞期(λ值=0.94 d)显著(P<0.05)低于其他预处理组(1.49~2.37 d)。相比而言,碱性过氧化氢(AH组)和芬顿试剂预处理(FE组)因过度降解青贮秸秆中的能源组分且木质素去除有限,对产甲烷性能形成了一定的抑制作用。经济收益分析表明,NG1组的净收益为968.20 yuan/t,较CK组提升了13.32%,经济效益最佳。因此,综合技术和经济指标结果,推荐采用摩尔比为0.1/1的GVL/NaOH预处理方案(NG1组),该研究为青贮玉米秸秆在沼气工程中的规模化应用奠定了基础。

       

      Abstract: Maize stover is one of the by-products or agricultural residues during production, particularly with a substantial yield and wide distribution. There is a significant energy conversion potential in the context of renewable and clean energy. The rational utilization of the maize stover can alleviate the energy shortages and environmental concerns. For instance, the improper stover disposal (such as open burning) can release a large amount of greenhouse gas. However, the compact microstructure of the maize stover has posed notable challenges to the effective energy conversion, due primarily to the complex cross-linking of lignin, cellulose, and hemicellulose. Some pretreatments, such as ensiling, have been employed to enhance the biodegradation and anaerobic digestion efficiency. However, there is still a lack of information on their impact on the digestibility of the raw materials. Particularly, it is often required to break down the rigid lignocellulosic matrix. This study aimed to improve the anaerobic digestion and methane production efficiency of ensiled maize stover. The chemical pretreatments were evaluated to clarify the influence mechanisms of the NaOH, γ-Valerolactone (GVL)/NaOH, alkaline hydrogen peroxide, and Fenton's reagent on the methanogenic performance, anaerobic digestion stability, and reaction of the ensiled maize stover. Both the energy conversion efficiency and economic benefits were also compared under different pretreatments from the perspectives of physicochemical properties, elemental composition, and microstructure. The results showed that the cellulose content of the pretreated NG1 group increased from 41.35% to 69.21%, and the hemicellulose content increased from 8.76% to 17.77%, whereas the lignin content decreased from 14.77% to 5.56% (81.76% removal rate), compared with the feedstock (CK group). The microstructure showed that the lignocellulosic structure of the NG1 group was severely damaged, and the total crystallinity index was significantly reduced (P<0.05). Moreover, the NG1 group maintained stable pH, optimal NH4+-N levels, and low IA (intermediate alkalinity)/PA (partial alkalinity) values (<0.6) during digestion, indicating the excellent system stability. Furthermore, the cumulative methane production of the NG1 group was as high as 375.17 mL/g (using volatile solids), which was 26.08% higher than that of the CK group; The maximum methane production rate was 25.43% higher than that of the CK group; And the lag period (λ value = 0.94 d) was significantly (P<0.05) lower than those of the rest pretreated groups (1.49~2.37 d). In contrast, the alkaline hydrogen peroxide (AH group) and Fenton's reagent pretreatment (FE group) resulted in the inhibition of the methanogenic performance, due to the excessive degradation of energy-containing components in the ensiled stover and limited lignin removal. The economic gain analysis showed that the net gain of the NG1 group was 968.20 yuan/t, which was 13.32% higher than that of the CK group, indicating the best economic benefit. Therefore, the technical and economic indices recommended the GVL/NaOH pretreatment with a molar ratio of 0.1/1. This finding can be extended into the large-scale application of the ensiled maize stover in biogas engineering. Practical guidance can also help optimize the anaerobic digestion of the ensiled maize stover for renewable energy. A technically feasible direction can be gained in the large-scale and efficient conversion of agricultural residues. Moreover, more sustainable agricultural waste management can greatly contribute to greenhouse gas emissions and the circular economy. A viable pathway can also be expected to enhance the economic and environmental sustainability of bioenergy production.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回