农田土壤铅有效态分析法(AB-DTPA)的优化与验证

    Optimization and validation of lead effective state analysis method ( AB-DTPA ) in farmland soils

    • 摘要: 中国土壤类型丰富多样,不同区域土壤重金属赋存形态各异,难以实现对不同区域不同类型土壤重金属有效性的比较与评价。为筛选建立适宜区域农田土壤重金属的有效性评价的方法,该研究选择滇东地区5种性质差异较大的典型农地土壤(黄棕壤、黄壤、红壤、石灰土和紫色土)运用正交试验法将AB-DTPA法的提取条件(固液比、提取剂pH值和振荡时间)进行正交组合,建立土壤-作物Pb迁移模型与总量法、CaCl2-DTPA法和AB-DTPA法进行拟合优度对比,并以白菜和菠菜为指示作物开展盆栽试验,探讨不同分析方法与作物Pb累积能力的相关性,进而综合评价不同方法的适宜性。结果表明,1)固液比(g/mL)1:3、提取剂pH值7.6以及振荡时间120 min对Pb有效态的提取量有较大的影响;2)与其他方法相比,优化AB-DTPA法(固液比1:3、pH值7.6和振荡时间120 min)能更好地预测作物对Pb的吸收能力;3)盆栽试验表明,优化AB-DTPA法提取的土壤 Pb有效态含量与白菜和菠菜吸收Pb含量具有更好的相关性(R2=0.898, R2=0.752),Pb的加标回收率范围为99.5%~113.0%,准确度高。4)将土壤pH值加入预测模型表明,土壤pH值对土壤Pb与在作物可食部分中相关性影响很小,表明优化AB-DTPA法很稳定。因此,优化AB-DTPA法适用于滇东地区农田土壤Pb有效态的提取,该法具有可行性、广普性和准确性。研究结果为区域农田土壤修复技术效果及污染风险评价提供基础依据。

       

      Abstract: The soil type in China are rich and diverse, and the occurrence forms of heavy metals in different regions are different. It is difficult to compare and evaluate the effectiveness of heavy metals in different regions and different types of soils. In order to screen and establish a method for evaluating the effectiveness of heavy metals in farmland soils in suitable areas, five typical farmland soils (yellow brown soil, yellow soil, red soil, lime soil and purple soil) with different properties in eastern Yunnan were selected. The extraction conditions (solid-liquid ratio, extractant pH value and oscillation time) of AB-DTPA method were orthogonally combined by orthogonal test, the soil-crop Pb migration model was established to compare the goodness of fit with the total method, CaCl2-DTPA method and AB-DTPA method. Pot experiments were carried out with Chinese cabbage and spinach as indicator plants to explore the correlation between different analysis methods and plant Pb accumulation ability, and then comprehensively evaluate the suitability of different methods.The results showed that the solid-liquid ratio (g/mL) 1:3, pH 7.6 and shaking time 120 min had a great influence on the extraction amount of Pb; The optimized AB-DTPA method (solid-liquid ratio (g/mL) 1:3, pH 7.6, and oscillation time of 120 min) obtained through orthogonal experimental screening has the best effect on predicting the effective state extraction amount of Pb and the amount of Pb absorbed by crops, which can better predict the crop's ability to absorb Pb; The pot experiment showed that the available Pb content extracted by the optimized AB-DTPA method had a better correlation with the Pb content absorbed by Chinese cabbage and spinach ( R2 = 0.898, R2 = 0.752 ), with a Pb spiked recovery rate range of 99.5%-113.0% and high accuracy. Therefore, the optimized AB-DTPA method (Solid-liquid ratio 1:3, pH 7.6 and shaking time 120 min) is suitable for the extraction of Pb available state in Yunnan farmland soil. The method is feasible, universal and accurate. The research results provide a basis for the effect of regional farmland soil remediation technology and pollution risk assessment.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回